Photos of nude kids in an art gallery. Obscene or not?

May 28th, 2008 by Eric Snider in The Morning Papers

There’s an obscenity brouhaha brewing in Australia over a prominent photographer’s use of 12- and 13-year-old models for a series of nude pictures that were hanging in a Sydney gallery until police seized them last week. Authorities are considering initiating an obscenity prosecution against photographer Bill Henson.

The Australian arts community has rallied to his defense. Among others, Cate Blanchett signed an open letter that said, in part, “The work itself is not pornographic, even though it included depictions of naked human beings …”

Here’s a link to the only online image that I could find.

Some of Henson’s backers have claimed that the photos are not sexual. I’m not buying that one. The pic I viewed didn’t do anything for me, but to my eyes it’s clearly sexual.

Is it obscene? I believe in the adage that you know obscene when you see it, and in this case, I do not see obscene. I don’t think Henson, who has shot a lot of stuff other than minors in the buff, should be hauled into court. As far as whether the 20 nudes should be hanging in a Sydney art gallery, I’m not so sure about that one.

But one of my colleagues did make an interesting point: That by seizing the artworks and condemning them, Australian authorities have sensationalized these photos. In effect, they’ve turned them into kiddie porn.


35 Responses to “Photos of nude kids in an art gallery. Obscene or not?”

  1. Gigi Says:

    So…about the underage kids in the photos…the moment you said something about how it should be taken as art, but maybe it doesn’t belong in a gallery, I had nothing left to bring to the table. The post was definitely thought-provoking, but there was no other conceivable, rational angle to hit that one from. Just add how sexy you thought the kids were and piss a couple moms off whydontcha?

  2. The Editor Says:

    Porn and art are in the eye of the beholder, but the question we should ask, is whether the subject consented, or was exploited or abused (regardless of the age).

    Pedophiles are perverted by all images of kids, no matter whether dressed or nude, because pedophiles are the problem, not the body beautiful.

  3. Dr. Paul Rapoport Says:

    “I believe in the adage that you know obscene when you see it”

    Then you believe in ignorant fantasy and mob lynching, which is exactly what is going on in this case. the fanatic critics are sexualizing an image in order to pretend that minors must never be sexual. George Orwell would have a fine time with all this.

  4. fashion Tiffany Necklaces Says:

    croum replica

    Rolex Day-Date II watches replica

  5. fashion Tiffany Necklaces Says:

    chopard watch for sale

    chopard watches replica

  6. croum watches Says:

    Rolex watches
    Rolex Air-King watches

  7. croum watches Says:

    Breitling watch for sale
    Burberry watch for sale

  8. Hermes Says:

    Hermes watches
    Hublot watches

  9. Rolex Says:

    Rolex Datejust II watch for sale
    Rolex Datejust watch for sale

  10. fashion Tiffany Necklaces Says:

    Bvlgari watches
    Cartier watches

  11. mac g4 power supply Says:

    mac g4 power supply
    mac g3 power supply

  12. Panerai watch for sale Says:

    replica Piaget
    replica Rado

  13. hanyu Says:

    Support of the Lou Zhu, Lou Zhu worked hard
    Signature——————————————————————————————————————–
    Nothing is impossible for a willing heart
    ugg Boots
    Signature——————————————————————————————————————–
    Nothing is impossible for a willing heart.
    ugg bailey button

  14. Longines watches Says:

    Longines watches
    Louis Vuitton watches

  15. Glashutte watch Says:

    Franck Muller watch for sale
    Glashutte watch for sale

  16. Christian Louboutin Pumps on sale Says:

    Christian Louboutin Pumps on sale
    Christian Louboutin Sandals on sale

  17. Manolo Blahnik Says:

    Chloe on sale
    Christian Louboutin Boots on sale

  18. Christian Louboutin Pumps Says:

    cheap YSL Platform
    discount YSL Platform

  19. discount Yves Saint Laurent Boots Says:

    discount Christian Louboutin SandalsChristian Louboutin Pumps

  20. Jimmy Choo Shoes Says:

    discount Jimmy Choo Handbags
    discount Jimmy Choo Shoes

  21. discount Yves Saint Laurent Boots Says:

    replica Rolex Day-Date II
    replica Yachtmaster

  22. Yves Saint Laurent Sandals Says:

    Christian Louboutin Fashion Boots
    cheap Christian Louboutin Fashion Boots

  23. Alexander McQueen Says:

    discount Alexander McQueen
    discount Chloe

  24. ugg boots sale,ugg boot Says:

    ugg boots sale
    ugg boot sale
    ugg classic mini
    ugg sundance boots
    ugg classic short
    newest style ugg boots
    ugg classic tall
    ugg cardy
    ugg ultra short
    ugg ultra tall
    ugg cardy boots

  25. Montblanc watches Says:

    Maurice Lacroix watches
    Montblanc watches

  26. IWC watch for sale Says:

    Rolex Daytona watch for sale
    Rolex Explorer watch for sale

  27. MBT Shoes Clearance Says:

    http://www.nikejordansale.com/
    We hope become your reliable online cheap goods supplier in china.Authentic goods with
    original box,we insists tha”Customer the highest,Quality first!”Our products include mbt
    shoes clearance,ugg classic tall sale,mens air jordan shoes,tiffany & co silver
    earrings and other cheap goods.We are looking forward to building sincere and long-term
    business relationships with you.

  28. China Wholesale Says:

    http://www.cheapgoodssale.com/
    We are the best online sales for the china wholesale . Here you can have a large of choices of kinds cheap ugg classic tall boots on sale,tiffany & co jewelry,tiffany and co silver earrings,tiffany cheap silver rings,mbt shoes on sale.All our cheap online cheap goods are high quality and original packages, and best service. We offer our customers the best service, 7 days arrive at your door.Enjoy your easy and happy shopping with us.

  29. cheap ugg classic tall boots on sale Says:

    http://www.cheapgoodssale.com/
    We are the best online sales for the china wholesale . Here you can have a large of choices of kinds cheap ugg classic tall boots on sale, tiffany & co jewelry,tiffany and co silver earrings, tiffany cheap silver rings,mbt shoes on sale,UGG Classic Cardy Boots,UGG Classic Mini Boots ,North Face Apparel,Cheap Sunglasses ,Dior Handbags,Prada Handbags,ED Hardy .All our online cheap goods are high quality and original packages, and best service. We offer our customers the best service, 7 days arrive at your door.Enjoy your easy and happy shopping with us.

  30. ugg boots sale Says:

    Ugg Boots Sale -Famous top quality Uggs with great discount are On Sale.
    We are the best Ugg Sale online store.

  31. ugg boots for sale Says:

    I received my ballot for the 2000 all-decade team from the Pro Football Hall of Fame last weekend

    When I’m asked to select any sort of all-star team, ugg store I prefer 22 players who can actually line up and play a game at their positions of choice.

    So I always pick weak- and strong-side ends, weak- and strong-side outside linebackers and free and strong safeties on defense. uggs outlet I also pick a right and left offensive tackle on offense plus a halfback and a fullback.

  32. m65 field jacket Says:

    thanks for the share

  33. tiffany Says:

    Tiffany Tiffany
    Tiffany jewellery Tiffany jewellery

  34. nick outlet Says:

    ugg outlet http://www.uggsoutletstores.org
    ugg black http://www.blackuggonsale.com

  35. chopard watches Says:

    replica Rolex Daytona
    replica Rolex Explorer

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image

SEARCH