American Idol - Women’s Top 12
February 21st, 2008 by Jeff Hahne in On TV / AwardsLast night, the top 12 girls sang and…well…they didn’t do much better than the guys.
I wasn’t impressed. Even Carly Smithson - the one with all the hype because of her record deal - didn’t do well.
I’d say the lone standout from either night was Syesha Mercado. The rest fall into a big pool of “sounds the same” or “boring.”
Four of the underachievers will be given the boot tonight.






Leave a Reply